You Can’t Judge a Book

By 

Matt Corton

(Story codes: MF, Exhib)


“Well I think we should go for it,” Jill said. “After all, if 
they’re good enough to let us use their facilities for our 
meetings and functions, the least we can do is support their 
fund raising events”

“That’s all well and good,” I replied, “but – I mean – Male 
Dancers? Let’s be honest here. We’re talking about strippers! 
I’m not sure I want to go to that kind of show. And I’m sure 
Moira doesn’t,” I added, looking around to Moira for moral 
support.

“I – I guess I’ll go along with the majority vote,” Moira said 
quietly, a distinct flush colouring her neck and face.

“It’s sure it’s not strippers” Jill replied. “Just dancers, you 
know, like the Chippendales.” She looked around the rest of 
the women seated around the conference table to elicit support.

I couldn’t believe we were having this conversation. The eight 
of us formed the management committee of the Orchardtown 
Ladies Welfare group, an organisation devoted to helping the 
elderly and infirm, hospital visiting, raising funds for good 
causes and so on. We held our fortnightly meetings at the 
Orchardtown Social Club, who very kindly allowed us to use 
their premises for meetings, jumble sales and tea dances. It 
seemed that the social club’s women members were staging a 
Ladies Night with “Exotic Entertainment provided by 
Studflesh,” according to the posters prominently displayed on 
the club’s notice boards, containing pictures of five muscle-
bound young men clad only in very skimpy briefs.

“I’m sure this is the dance group my sister saw on holiday last 
year,” another of our ladies said. “She said they were very, you 
know, er, graphic.”  This raised a gaggle of titters from around 
the table. 

After another round of discussions the votes were cast. There 
were six votes for, with just Moira and I voting against. 
Honestly, that Jill! I could have stamped my feet in 
exasperation. She might enjoy that kind of entertainment, but 
the others hadn’t got a clue what they were letting themselves 
into. Poor Moira would be totally out of her depth. And me? 
Well, I didn’t go for men, actually, but that’s another story.

Moira is a lovely woman and one of my best friends. Although 
in her early thirties, she still lives with her parents in the family 
home. Now, I know it’s a bit of a cliché, but Moira is the living 
example of the archetypal librarian. A shy, bookish woman, 
always impeccably but ultra-conservatively dressed. Horn-
rimmed glasses and hair neatly tied in a tight bun. Never heard 
to utter a rude word. Always blushes demurely at the merest 
suggestion that sexual activity existed. Never been known to 
have a boyfriend. Don’t get me wrong, it’s not that she prefers 
girls - believe me, I would know. No, Moira was simply the 
type who would grow into an old maid, and I would bet my life 
savings that she was a virgin.

And so the evening of the Ladies Night arrived. Moira and I 
arrived at the social club together having been given a lift by 
one of the other ladies. I was glad of this because I was sure as 
hell going to need a drink to get through the night. Moira 
didn’t drive. As we entered the hall we could here Jill shouting 
“Over here girls! I’ve got us a table right at the front!” Oh 
God! What have I done to deserve this? I thought to myself. It 
was all I could do to raise a half smile as I said hello to the 
girls.

Eventually the compere introduced the evening’s 
entertainment. During the first half we were to be treated to an 
“artistic dancing display” by each of the five members of 
Studflesh, apparently. After the interval, “Well, that depends 
upon you ladies, nudge wink,” the weasel faced man 
announced with a suggestive leer. God, I needed another drink.

Much to my surprise the hall was packed with woman. The 
first young man came on stage wearing a Tarzan outfit and, 
accompanied by jungle-like music and a raucous cacophony of 
whoops and yells he proceeded to strip down to the skimpiest 
thong-like garment imaginable. Where he put his male 
equipment, God alone knew.

The second, third and fourth acts performed tiresomely similar 
acts. Only the outfits seemed to change. They had clearly 
gained their inspiration from the Village People as we went 
through an American motor cycle policeman, a red Indian and 
a builder. Not that the crowd seemed to mind. They hooted and 
screamed and hollered like fishwives. “Get ‘em off!” and 
“Show us your willy!” were the most common of the witty 
pieces of repartee delivered. Even Jill, and – heaven forbid – 
most of my fellow committee members seemed to be enjoying 
themselves immensely.

God, I needed another drink. 

Moira looked pale, and I was both sorry that she was here and 
angry that Jill had bull-dozed through the vote for us to attend. 
I brought Moira a glass of white wine. I knew that she rarely 
touched alcohol but I realised that she needed something to 
bolster her spirits.

The fifth act arrived on stage as the compere announced him as 
the newest member of the group. He was dressed in a cowboy 
outfit, complete with chaps, spurs, gun belt and cowboy hat. 
He was swinging a lasso as he walked about the stage. Now he 
was a good looking boy, even I had to admit. He had curly 
blonde hair, blue eyes and he exuded an air of youthful 
exuberance and freshness that was undeniably attractive, even 
to one such as me. He too danced and stripped to his 
underwear, flexing muscles and making erotic poses, but he 
was different somehow – at least he seemed so to me. He 
possessed a certain air of vulnerability, of being aware of and 
embarrassed by his own near nudity. Somehow the others 
exuded an impression of being totally accustomed to being 
ogled at by a large group of half-drunk women. But not 
Cowboy, he seemed more aware of his own near nudity..

“Isn’t it wonderful?” Jill said at the interval, clapping her 
hands and yelling with excitement. “Oh, I did love that red 
Indian…” She busied herself chatting about the various merits 
of the different young men who had paraded themselves for 
our so-called entertainment.

“Are you OK, Moira?” I asked, concerned that she was hating 
this entire event. The lights had come up and could detect a 
bright flush on her face. Must be the wine, I thought.

“Er, yes. I’m OK,” She replied, raising a thin smile. “I think I 
might just slip away during the second half though. Mother 
doesn’t like me to be too late on a week-day.”

“Very sensible of you, my dear,” I said, patting her arm.

The lights dimmed for the second half. The compere arrived on 
stage. “Ladies – welcome to part two,” he said over the public 
address system. “Now, if you think the first half was good, you 
ain’t seen nothing yet!” He raised his arms and elicited a loud 
chorus of wolf-whistles and cheers from the crowd.

“Now, in part two, if you show my lads the proper 
encouragement, who can tell how far they’ll go, if you know 
what I mean?” He grinned leeringly to another huge round of 
applause and cheering. “But be warned ladies. If you’re of a 
nervous or easily offended disposition, you should leave now. 
Although, if you’re easily offended, what the hell are you 
doing here in the bleedin’ first place?” Another round of noise 
accompanied this. “But be especially warned ladies. One or 
two of the lads might invite you onto the stage to, er, assist 
them. Please don’t go with them unless you’re very 
broadminded!” 
  
Oh God. I need another drink, I thought. I went to the bar, 
returning with my drink and another white wine for Moira.

The second half started as a near repeat of the first half, except 
that after a minute or two Tarzan came into among the 
audience. He looked around then went over to a group of 
women several tables to our left. Accompanied by a raucous 
round of cheering and yelling he led a short, rotund woman of 
about forty onto the stage.

He took off his leotard, placed it behind his assistant’s back 
and started to rub it up and down here body. He whispered 
something in her ear, and with a huge guffaw she stripped off 
her T shirt, unhooked her enormous bra and started to wiggle 
her breasts in time to the beat of the accompanying jungle 
music. 

The crowd went wild. Tarzan pointed to his briefs with one 
hand, and cupped ear with the other as if to better hear 
something from crowd. His half-naked helper must have 
understood, as she started to encourage the crowd to chant 
“Off, off, off, off, off.” Tarzan turned his back to the audience 
and slowly peeled down his underwear, finally kicking the 
garment clear. He turned around, hands on hips, stark naked. 
The spectators went wild as he posed, penis in hand in a 
variety of positions.  After a few moments, the lights went off 
and he left the stage to huge applause.

God, I needed another drink.
This set the scene for the next three acts. They all found 
someone in the audience to accompany them on stage. All of 
them attempted to persuade their assistants to take off their 
own clothes. Two women did actually remove their tops but 
refused to take off their bras, the other simply wouldn’t co-
operate despite the performer’s strong encouragement. All 
three of these muscle-bound men ended up naked, one of them 
having persuaded his female assistant to remove his briefs with 
her teeth.

I was expecting Moira to leave at any time. She was barely 
watching the stage and I knew that the nudity and, well, 
squalor of it all would offend her. The problem though, was 
that she couldn’t really leave without the entire hall noticing, 
as there was no gap between the performances and the 
audience from the back of the hall had begun to surround the 
tables at the front, like ours, to get a better look. Moira was 
stuck between her dislike of the entertainment, and her 
unwillingness to make a fuss by fighting her way through the 
throng to leave.

Finally, it was Cowboy’s turn to perform once more. His 
descent from the stage to the floor was slower than the others, 
almost hesitant - as if he didn’t have the confidence to 
approach the audience. He glanced about, and to my horror but 
to Jill’s squeals, he headed straight towards our table! I could 
see Jill almost leaning out of her seat to put herself in front of 
him for selection as his assistant. I heard myself say “Oh my 
God,” however, as he walked straight past her and reached his 
hand out towards Moira.

With complete and total astonishment I watched her extend her 
arm for Cowboy to take her hand, allowing him to lead her 
slowly onto the stage.

“Bloody hell!” I heard Jill say. Me, I couldn’t speak at all. 
What the hell was she doing up there? Hadn’t she seen the 
others and what went on up there? She’ll positively die! With 
difficulty I overcame the temptation to rush onto the stage and 
drag her back. 

Cowboy began his act by dancing slowly around Moira to the 
accompaniment of a haunting Western-style tune. She stood 
there in her grey business-style suit, jacket fastened, skirt 
sitting correctly three inches below the knees. Cream blouse, 
buttoned to the neck. She was even wearing tights, for God’s 
sake. The only apparent change from her normal appearance at 
the library was that her auburn hair was down and she had 
contact lenses instead of glasses – not that this loosened her 
appearance up at all -Moira just didn’t know how to appear 
casual.

The male dancer removed his chaps, gun belt, shirt and boots, 
followed by his trousers. He was reduced to a pair of white 
briefs and, incongruously to me at any rate, his hat. He began 
to dance around Moira again. I watched in amazement as he 
unbuttoned her grey jacket and, walking behind her, removed 
it from her shoulders, placing it in the ground behind them.

They began to dance, or rather to sway together to the slow 
beat of the tune. His hands were in front of him and we could 
see his fingers working. Good God! I nearly yelled out in 
shock as I realised that he was unbuttoning her blouse. Surely 
not!

But yes, he did indeed unbutton the garment. Not only that, but 
he once again moved around behind her and removed it from 
her upper body, exposing a black brassiere tinged with red 
lace. I started to realise something I had never noticed before. 
Moira was a very attractive girl. While I was admiring her 
cleavage, Cowboy must have unbuttoned her skirt and 
unfastened the zip, because he then began to ease the garment 
down her hips. Slowly, inch by inch the skirt descended until 
with a final rush it fell around her feet. She lifted her feet and 
stepped away from the clothing.

I nearly fainted with shock. Not only because Moira, my quiet, 
pathologically shy friend had permitted this man to strip 
her down to her underwear, but also because her 
undergarments consisted of sheer silk stockings – not 
tights as I had assumed - held in place by suspenders and 
a scanty thong to match the black and red bra. I had to 
close my eyes, shake my head and look again to verify 
what I had just seen.

The crowd loved it. They were cheering and clapping and 
yelling as Cowboy knelt in front of her and unfastened her 
stockings, slowly peeling them down each leg in turn. He 
removed the suspenders leaving Moira exposed in just her bra 
and panties.

She placed her hands on his hips as he held her again and they 
began to dance around the stage once again. Her eyes were 
closed and she wore a dazed expression as if this was 
happening to someone else and not to her. I watched her 
intently, and – surely not – oh my God – she was gently 
stroking a finger up and down the front of his briefs. From my 
position I could clearly see his penis becoming erect, straining 
against the fabric of his underwear. He held her tighter and, 
turning her around so that he shielded her briefly from the 
audience, he unhooked her bra. I don’t even think Moira 
noticed. He lowered his hand and now began to caress the 
inside of her groin. Her lips opened and I’m sure a groan 
escaped from her, lost in the noise of the crowd.

He pulled away from her slightly, then reached forward and 
removed her bra. God, her breasts were exquisite. I could 
clearly see her nipples erect and pouting and I started to squirm 
in my seat with sexual excitement just from looking at her. She 
was gorgeous. What I would have given to be in Cowboy’s 
place!

With his back to the audience, Cowboy lowered his briefs, 
affording the crowd of woman a full view of his tight buttocks. 
A collective sigh arose from the hall, followed by gasps as he 
turned around and faced them full-frontally naked – apart from 
his hat. Not only naked, but with a rock hard erection pointing 
towards every one of his captivated audience. 

Now, trust me I’m not an expert on the subject of male 
erections for reasons you’ve probably guessed by now. But 
even with my limited experience I knew that this cock was in 
the premiere league. It was large, and thick and as stiff as a 
steel rod, and it protruded from him at an angle that seemed to 
look each of his spectators straight in the eye. A hush settled 
over the hall as two hundred (well, one hundred and ninety-
nine) fantasies were given birth.

But my eyes gaze returned quickly to Moira. Her eyes had 
glazed over and her entire body appeared to be flushed. By 
looking closely I swear I could see a damp patch form at the 
front of her panties. Now seemingly oblivious to the fact that 
she was being observed by a large crowd she stepped forward 
and began to stroke his penis.

Cowboy broke away, took her hand and led her across the 
stage to one of the large floor-mounted speakers used by the 
PA system. He sat Moira down upon it, then gently leaned her 
backwards until she lay flat upon it. He turned towards the 
crowd and pointed at her one remaining item of clothing. 
Someone took the hint and in a few moments the chant of “off, 
off, off, off” began, accompanied by a thunder of hand claps in 
time.

Cowboy peeled down her panties. Her legs were slightly apart 
and the entire hall could clearly see the exposed lips of her 
labia. He wasted no time in positioning his stiff member at the 
entry to her vagina and with a sudden thrust he buried himself 
deep within her. To the beat of the clapping audience he 
pummelled in and out, in and out until both he and Moira cried 
out in orgasmic ecstasy.  At the same time, someone in 
authority realised that several criminal laws were being broken 
on stage and the lights were switched off, plunging us into 
darkness.

I’m ashamed to say that I too as carried away by the intense 
sensuality of the encounter. Almost without being aware I had 
allowed my hand to slide inside my trousers, easing aside my 
knickers to stroke my clitoris. I climaxed in seconds, 
completely unobserved by those around me. Nevertheless to 
this day I carry with me the frightening thought that I lost 
control sufficiently to masturbate in the middle of a crowd of 
two hundred people.

I met Moira at the stage door about twenty minutes later. The 
area had emptied. She was once again fully dressed and looked 
exactly as if nothing had happened. The rest of our group had 
left in the same confused state of sexual frustration as the rest 
of the audience. No-one had spoken a word. 

“Are you OK?” I asked her stupidly.

“Marvellous!” she giggled. “That was absolutely, fucking 
brilliant. What a fantastic shag.”

“Moira!” I said, shocked to the core.

“Oh don’t give me that Miss goody-two-shoes,” she said, still 
smiling. “I know you wanted what was on the stage as much as 
I did.”

Well, I had her there, I thought. “That’s where you’re wrong, 
Moira. In fact I don’t even like men.”

“I didn’t mean the Cowboy,” she said. And with that she 
leaned over and kissed me full on the lips. Her tongue entered 
my mouth, its tip running gently along my own. My head 
began to swim and my stomach turn cartwheels. “Are you 
going to take me home with you?” she whispered. “I’m still as 
horny as hell.”

“Oh Moira,” I groaned, my hand at her breast, the memory of 
her naked body causing me to flood with desire. “I – I had no 
idea that – that you….”

“That I can swing both ways?” she answered. “Listen, I’m the 
librarian and I’m telling you. You can’t judge a book………”

I completed her sentence. “By its cover,” I whimpered.