An Honest Mistake

By Jacqueline Jillinghoff

I

I was upstairs doing my weights when I saw the light go on across the street. The girl came into her mother’s bedroom. Her and her mom only moved in about two weeks before, and I never paid that much attention to her, but I paid attention this time because she was nude.

Her house was one of those square stucco jobs people thought were modern back in the fifties. The second floor had a big picture window in front. The blinds were up and there were no curtains, so I could see everything, the whole bedroom. This was after nine o’clock in mid-October, and with the bright ceiling light on, the room seemed to be floating in the darkness. The naked girl looked small from where I was standing, but her body was bright and sharp under the light.

She was just a kid, with no tits and skinny legs. I didn’t see any hair on her crotch, but she was a light blonde, and it was hard to tell at that distance. The hair on her head hung far down her back, and she had flat abs like mine. I exercised to get that way. She didn’t need to yet.

She tiptoed to her mother’s dresser on the other side of the bed and started going through the drawers. She was looking for something, and it was something her mother didn’t want her to know about, because she was feeling under the bras and panties and nightgowns and pushing the jewelry aside.

Whatever it was, she didn’t find it. After a bit she gave up and stood in front of the dresser, looking at herself in the mirror. She did this beautiful move where she dipped to the side and swung her hair back over her shoulder. I could see her face in profile. From the side, her butt was a gorgeous white half-moon.

She put her hands over her chest, like she was trying to hide the tits she didn’t have. She rubbed her nipples, then she put one hand down her leg and around her front, and her elbow and her upper arm started pumping, slowly.

I decided I’d had enough weightlifting for one night. I put the dumbbells down and turned off the lamp next to my bed, and I stood there in the dark watching her.

Her arm went faster. Her knees slipped. She sort of pitched forward, and she had to put her other hand on the dresser to steady herself. Her hair fell over her chest again. She straightened up and turned around, and she looked back at her butt in the mirror. Her face was turned toward me. She would have definitely caught me looking at her if my light was still on — and if she wasn’t so into herself.

Now I could see her hand over her crotch. She was pumping up and down with her fingers pushing into her slot. She hunched over again, and I guess she decided it was too much trouble to stand up while she played with herself. She took a couple of hops to the bed — bent over with her fingers between her legs — and she spun around and flopped on her back.

She found what she had been looking for as soon as her head hit the pillow. That’s where her mother hid it. She lifted her head and reached behind her neck, and she came out with this thing that looked like a microphone — a short black wand with a black knob at one end.

That’s when I remembered my binoculars.

“Fuck! I’m an idiot,” I said.

I ran back to my closet and got them. They’re not much — only 7 by 35 — but I got them cheap at a yard sale, and they’re good for bird watching with my group — and for spying on little girls playing with their pussies.

I threw the case on the bed, and as I ran back to the window, I dropped the plastic lens caps on the floor. One of the little ones rolled under my bed. I put the binocular about and inch from the window and looked.

The view was bright but blurry. I diddled the wheel. The blurs got tighter and took on shapes — arms and feet and a head — and then she snapped into focus.

The bed faced the window, so I was looking up at her crotch between the bottoms of her feet. And no, she didn’t have any hair between her legs — just smooth white pubes with a dark pinhole in the middle. She was holding the wand straight up, pressing the knob against the top of her slit, and that pink-gray flap there that looks like a tongue sticking out sideways. For a long time she didn’t move. Then her toes curled, like she was waving them at me, and she stretched her legs. She crossed one foot over the other and squeezed her thighs together. She closed her eyes. It looked like she was talking to herself, but I couldn’t make out any words. Finally, she threw her head back and opened her mouth wide. She might have been screaming or wailing, but it was like watching TV with the sound off.

Bad!

Bad! Bad! Bad! That’s what my mother yelled every time the hairbrush hit my ass the time she caught me touching myself. Like I was a dog that peed on the rug. I was little, younger even than the girl across the street, and I didn’t know I was doing anything wrong. It just felt good, but she whaled on my ass so hard she turned it black and blue. I couldn’t sit down for a day — literally — and I never touched myself like that again.

Until now. The girl across the street was being bad — worse than I ever was — and she was loving it. It was like she was out of her mind. I wanted to go out of my mind, too.

I squeezed my nipples through my muscle shirt. They were hard as bolts. The pleasure shot down to my crotch, like my tits were connected to my pussy with wires. But I needed three hands. I couldn’t pinch my nips, jigger my cunt, and hold the binoculars at the same time. I had to make a choice, and I chose my cunt. My hand went down the front of my boxers.

Just then the girl pulled her knees up, which gave me a Cinemascope view of her twat. She slid the knob down the pink flap and shoved it halfway into her hole.

The wand looked like a stick shift in her pussy. She moved it around like one, too, jacking it up and down and switching it from side to side, before she pushed it all the way over against her thigh and froze. That was the position she was looking for — it must have made her feel like everything inside her was buzzing all at once. Her chest heaved. Her ribs stuck out each time she sucked in air and then kind of melted under her skin when she let it out again. She worked her mouth like a fish. I couldn’t tell what she was saying — it might have been “wow-wow-wow” or “whoa-oa-oa,” or she might have been just making faces — but I knew what she was feeling, because I was feeling it, too.

My cunt was sopping. I had three fingers up inside it and my thumb mashed down on my joy button and I was jerking my wrist hard. The binoculars kept smacking the window and jamming the eyepieces into my face. But I did not care. I never felt anything so awesome in my life.

When the girl’s shoulders bucked and her head bounced on the pillow and she dug in her heels and pushed her ass off the mattress — when that happened, the first orgasm I have ever had in my life kicked me in the twat. Everything got tighter, more wound up, and then I dropped off a cliff. Nobody ever told me anything could be like this. Damn you, Mom — it feels good! I wanted to scream like the kid was doing, but Mom and Dad were downstairs watching TV, and I didn’t dare. So I bit my lip and grunted and moaned. The great feeling passed, and I slowed down with my hand, but I sped up again when it came back. I went around like that three or four times — fast, slow, fast— until I couldn’t do it anymore.

The girl couldn’t do it anymore, either. She was lying there with the vibrator sticking out of her cunt. She had this stupid look on her face, kind of a silly grin with her eyes closed. I was feeling goofy, too, and I puckered up and sent her a kiss across the street.

“Mwah! That’s for you,” I said. “Thank you, thank you, thank you.”

Yeah, sex is good. Big news, right? But it took a kid nine or ten years younger than me to teach me that.

She also taught me why it’s better to do it lying down. I couldn’t get my knees and my ankles to lock. I couldn’t stand up straight. I was weak all over. I couldn’t even hold up the binoculars. I lowered them to the floor, gently, by the strap, and I rested my forehead against the window. That’s when I saw the lights from a car throwing shadows down the street. The car came in from the right a couple seconds later and turned into the driveway next to the girl’s house. Her mom was home.

I got scared, thinking maybe if she caught her, she’d do to her what my mom did to me.

“Get out of there,” I said. “Come on, come on, get out of there.”

But the girl didn’t move. She looked like she was asleep.

The engine died, and the taillights went off, and the car door opened and shut. The mom walked to the front door, which was actually on the side of the house. There was a streetlamp about halfway to the corner. The light came through the trees behind her. Patches of shadow moved down the back of her coat. I could see her cheeks, too. They were bright and pale, like a ghost’s.

I looked from one to the other. A second after the mom got inside, the girl raised her head and called out something. She didn’t look scared, but she didn’t want to hang around, either. She moved fast, but not like she was panicked. First she pulled the vibrator out of her hole. Then she got up and put it back under the pillow, smoothed out the bedspread, and left the room. The last thing I saw was that cute white butt going out the door as she snapped off the light.

I stood there a while in the dark — not looking at anything, just fingering my pussy and getting my strength back. Maybe I was worried for nothing. Maybe her mom wasn’t a ghoul about sex like mine was. And maybe I could start having fun. All through high school I never thought much about boys. I told myself it was because I didn’t need the hassle of dating under my mother’s nose, but now I knew the real reason. I wanted a cunt to play with.

My life just got more complicated.

 

II

Now, to understand what happened next, you should know what I look like. I’m thin, and I have kind of a square face, with a sharp chin, and big brown eyes. My hair is brown, and I wear it short and combed across my forehead. The day I met the girl across the street, I had on my straight-leg jeans turned up at the ankles, and my oxblood loafers, and my brown tweed suit jacket, and a blue Oxford cloth shirt and a sweater vest. When I’m layered like that, you can’t tell I have tits. I wasn’t butch, exactly, just kind of boyish, which I guess is what started the trouble.

Then there’s my name, but I’ll get to that.

I remember it was a Thursday because that’s the day I only worked a couple hours at the health food store, and then I went down to Community for my class. I was taking business math — always trying to improve myself. Anyway, it was about four o’clock, and I was home for the day. The train left me off a block from where I live. The sky was bright bright blue, and the leaves were yellow and starting to fall. I was coming down the sidewalk, carrying my books in a tote bag, and I saw two kids hanging out in front of my house.

They went to Nativity, the little Catholic school next to the station. They were still in their uniforms, covered in Navy from the neck down. The boy had on blue slacks and a blue bowtie that peeked out over his blue sweater. He looked like he should have been selling ice cream.

But the girl was adorable, in her pleated skirt and knee socks, and those white saddle shoes with the blue stripes. The school sweater really set off her blonde hair, which was long and loose and messy over her shoulders. I recognized her from half a block away because of the hair, and my cunt sort of melted when I remembered the way it looked through the window, hanging down her naked back.

The boy was showing off for her. We live on a narrow, dead-end street on the side of a hill, and my house is on the uphill side. You walk up like a dozen steps to get to the front porch, and the boy was running up the steps and sliding back down the railing, face first, sort of side-saddle. He spread his arms to keep his balance, and he went so fast that when he hit the sidewalk, the momentum carried him into the street. I saw him do it twice before I reached them.

“You two having fun?” I said.

“I’m trying to get her to do it,” the boy said.

“Why don’t you?” I asked the girl.

“She’s scared to,” the boy said.

“Maybe the people who live here don’t want you sliding down their railing,” I said. “You might get hurt.”

“I won’t get hurt,” the boy said.

“And you might break it,” I said.

“It’s not your property,” the boy said.

“Yeah, it is.”

“Gotcha!” the girl said — the first word I ever heard her say. “You’re in trouble now!”

“No, he’s not,” I said. “I don’t mind. I used to do it myself.”

“Really?” the boy said.

“Yeah, just like that. Why don’t you try it?”

“I don’t know,” the girl said.

“I told you she was scared,” the boy said.

“Come on. I’ll catch you,” I said.

The girl went up the steps slowly, like she on her way to be hanged. The boy went with her. I put down my tote bag.

“Just sit on it the way he showed you,” I called up. “Sit straight up. Don’t lean.”

She lifted one leg and settled herself on the railing. The boy took hold of her shoulders and swiveled her around toward the front. He didn’t have to do that. I think it was just an excuse to touch her.

Then she lifted the other leg, and down she came. Zip! Halfway down her skirt flew up, and for a split-second I saw her panties. They were red and white, striped across, like the flag.

She slapped her skirt down when she came off the railing, and I caught her under the arms. My thumbs were over her nipples. We looked into each other’s eyes. Hers were shiny and pale blue.

“That was cool!” she said.

“My name’s Jesse,” I said. “What’s yours?”

“Gretchen,” she said.

“The woman who lived in the house before you was named Gretchen, too,” I said.

“That was my grandmom,” she said. “We got the house when she died.”

The boy slid down the railing a third time and landed next to us.

“This is Joey,” Gretchen said, right on cue.

The moment was over. I had to let her go.

“How are you, Joey?”

“OK.”

I held out my hand. I don’t know why, except I suddenly felt self-conscious. We shook.

“Is your mother home yet?” I said.

“She won’t be home till later,” Gretchen said.

“Mine, neither,” I said. “You want to come up for some pie? I have organic cherry. You, too,” I told Joey.

“Sure,” Gretchen said.

“I thought we were gonna go to your house,” Joey said.

“I want some pie,” Gretchen insisted.

“Uh oh, did I ruin your date?” I said.

He didn’t know what to say to that, so he just mumbled, “That’s OK...” And he picked up his bookbag up from the curb.

“Stick around,” I said.

“I hafta get home,” he said. “My mom’ll be mad.”

“OK, see ya,” Gretchen said.

He put a hand on her shoulder and leaned over to give her a kiss — on the lips — but she turned her head and he got her cheek instead.

“See ya,” he said, though he didn’t sound like he was looking forward to it, and he walked away up the street.

“He’s cute,” I said.

“He’s OK.”

“Is he your boyfriend?”

“No! He just walks me home.”

“It’s only half a block. He must like you.”

“I guess, but he’s too young.”

“Aren’t you the same age?”

“Yeah, but his dick can’t get hard.”

“I’m sorry... What!?”


So Joey went home in a sulk, and me and Gretchen we went up to my kitchen. I heated up a couple slices of pie in the oven, and served them with soymilk and rice ice cream from Henry’s, and she told me what she knew about dicks. Which, it turned out, was a lot.

“Me and Joey took off all our clothes yesterday when my mom wasn’t home,” she said. “We kissed and everything, but he couldn’t put it in me. I like pulled on it and sucked on it, but nothing happened.”

She took a big bite of pie and washed it down with a big swallow of soymilk. I’d lost my appetite.

“Couldn’t Joey do anything?’

“He felt me up and licked my pussy, and that was OK, but I really wanted to fuck.”

“What do you know about fucking?” I said.

“I had a boyfriend in my old neighborhood,” she said. “We did it.”

“Did what?”

Fucked.

“You’re shitting me.”

“Uh uh.”

“How old are you?”

“Ten.”

“And how old was he?”

“I don’t know. He was in high school. He was gonna be a senior.”

“And he fucked you?”

“A couple times.”

“What was that like?”

“It was really cool.”

“Your boyfriend sounds horrible. What kind of sick kid would fuck a ten-year-old?”

“Hey! He was great. We were gonna get married.”

“I’ll bet.”

“Stop it!”

She looked down at her plate. I reached over and touched her gently on the back of the neck.

“I’m sorry,” I said. “You really loved him, didn’t you?”

Her head moved a little.

“So what are you gonna do?”

She sniffled and looked up at me. Her eyes were red.

“I don’t know,” she said.

“You hafta to find somebody older.”

“I don’t know anybody.”

“You know me,” I said. “I could be your boyfriend.”

“Really?”

“Yeah, I mean ... we could pretend. Until you find somebody else who can give you what you want.”

She didn’t day anything to that. I stroked her neck, and he she gave me a half smile. So I leaned over and kissed her. She didn’t turn her head away, either, the way I saw her do with Joey. It was my first kiss, but for sure it wasn’t hers. She knew just what to do. She opened her mouth wide and her tongue filled my mouth. She wanted it bad, and that was fine with me.

It got uncomfortable, though, leaning across the corner of the kitchen table like that. So I took her hands and drew her over to me. She sat on my lap and put her arms around my neck. I put my hand up between her legs. They were so smooth. We stuck out our tongues and licked them together while I massaged her through her panties. She opened her legs, and I rubbed harder, but slow, pressing down with four fingers, and going deep down into her crotch.

“God, I’m so horny,” she said, and she mashed her lips against mine.

I rubbed her and rubbed her. The cotton was damp. There was the tough lump near the top of her pussy, and underneath, it was softer, and wetter. She grunted into my mouth, and all of a sudden she reached down and stopped my hand moving. Then she pulled her head back and looked at me.

“You wanna do it?” she said, all out of breath.

“Do it?”

“Yeah, come on,” she said. She slid off my lip. “Stand up.”

I got up, and she knelt down in front of me and started pulling at my belt. I got out of my jacket and my vest. She undid my jeans and pulled them halfway down my thighs. I was wearing plain white panties.

“It’s OK,” I said. “Go ahead.”

But she wasn’t so eager anymore.

“Here,” I said. I pushed my panties down myself, and she fell back on her heels like I slapped her.

“What’s wrong?” I said.

“Where is it?” she said.

“Where’s what?” I said.

The quarter dropped.

“What — you thought I was a guy?

“You said you’d be my boyfriend!”

“I said we could pretend!”

She got up and grabbed her schoolbag.

“Wait a minute,” I said. “Girls can still do it.”

“You’re weird,” she said.

She ran out through the living room. It was hard to follow her, holding my pants up with my ass hanging out, and she was almost at the door before I caught up with her.

“Don’t go,” I said. “We don’t have to do anything.”

She had her hand on the doorknob, and when I grabbed her around her shoulders. I squeezed her to me and kissed her on the head and the back of her neck while I pulled her over to the couch. I had to take small steps, ‘cause my pants were around my knees. She squirmed and kicked, but — you know — she was a kid.

“Just calm down,” said. “I won’t do anything bad.”

“Let me go!”

“Shut up!”

I threw her down on the couch. I didn’t want to keep her prisoner or anything, but I wasn’t going to let her go without a taste of that pussy. I guess I got crazy.

I pried her schoolbag from her fingers. Then I put my hands up under her skirt and grabbed her panties by the waistband. She curled into a ball, and when she brought her feet up, one of her shoes banged me in the lip. But now her butt was showing underneath, and it was easy to roll her panties up and over her knees. I heard them rip when I got them off one shoe, and I thought the hell with it, that’s good enough. I left them hanging off her other ankle.

Then I got my hands between her knees, and I pushed in two directions, like I was force open an elevator door. She kept her legs rigid, but once I got them apart just a little, the elevator snapped open.

Her pussy was different up close — fuller, with all the crinkles and bulges. It was shimmering pink, with glob of grayish-white cream plugging the hole.

I dove in and slurped it out.

The kid stopped squirming.

I wasn’t sure if she came when we were in the kitchen, but I know she came this time. I licked out her cunt-hole and swiped her clit, just like I imagined some girl doing to me. It settled her down. She wasn’t freaked out anymore. She got still, with her eyes closed, sort of drawing into herself, until she let out a grunt — sort of a big HUH!

“You still want to leave?” I said.

She just grinned and kept her eyes closed, her head hanging to one side, and I ate her out some more. She put one leg over my shoulder and thumped me in the shoulder blade with the heel of one of those oversize shoes. That was my second injury, but I kept going. Her legs got stiff again, but not like before, when she was trying to get away. She arched her back and sighed big-time, and she was done. She pushed my head away a little.

“Was that nice?” I said, still kissing the insides of her legs and the bald white lips.

“Uh huh,” she said, kind of dreamy.

“See? A girl can be just as good.”

I started pawing at her clothes, unbuttoning her skirt and pushing up her sweater. She didn’t care. I got her skirt down her legs and I was pulling off her shoes when she sat up and pulled her sweater off over her head. She let me unbutton her blouse. In half a minute she was naked, except for the deep-blue knee socks. Those she pulled up.

“Don’t you want to take them off?” I said.

“My feet are cold.”

“So’s my butt.”

“I never really...” she said.

“Never really what?”

“Saw another girl.”

“You never saw another girl naked?”

“Not up close.”

“You want a look?”

“OK,” she said.

Like I was doing her the favor. I stood up, and I gave her a naughty smirk while I unbuttoned my shirt and toed off my shoes. I was glad to get my pants off, because I felt stupid with them hanging down like they were. When I got everything off, I laid down on the sofa with her, stuffing myself between her and the cushions on the back.

This is what I wanted since the first time I saw her — kissing, nude, with our bodies touching all over and our fingers up each other’s cunts. But she couldn’t stay still. She wanted to go exploring. She got me under her somehow, jerking us around a little bit at a time, and she kissed me on the neck and shoulders and farther and farther down.

“Your tits look like my mom’s,” she said.

“Hers are bigger,” I said. Everybody’s were.

“Yeah, but you got the same nipples,” she said. “They stick straight out.”

“Put your mouth around it,” I said, squeezing one toward her.

I sighed with pleasure when she sucked on it. My cunt spasmed a little —kind of a sympathetic twinge. It wasn’t crazy wild, like when I spied on her and frigged myself, but it was ... nicer. I smoothed my hands down her bare back, under her hair, and over her pretty little ass, to let her know she was doing it right.

She went down more, licking all down my sides and under my tits and over my pelvis, and cleaning out my navel with her tongue.

I let one foot fall to the floor, giving her some room, and she reached in and pulled my inner lips apart with her fingers.

“You got a lot of hair,” she said.

“You’ll get yours.”

“Was I this gooey?”

“You were pretty wet,” I said.

“I can’t find the button.”

“Don’t you know where yours is?”

“Yeah, but you’re all turned around.”

“Near the top, under all the folds.”

“Show me.”

I pressed two fingers on either side of my cunt, and the little pill popped out between them.

“What do girls taste like?”

“Find out.”

She touched her tongue to it.

“Darling—,” I said.

Her mouth suddenly covered my pussy. The whole room pitched over. Then it sprang up again and dipped to the other side. The painting over the sofa went double. I focused on Gretchen, trying to keep my stomach from churning. Her mouth was hidden between my legs, so I couldn’t tell if she was smiling, but her eyes sparkled with mischief. I caressed her blonde hair, taking it loosely in my fists, stroking her head. She went deeper into my pussy. Her nose plowed my bush.

My cunt twitched again, then it sort of clenched, and my orgasm bubbled up from just where her tongue touched my clit. Something in me broke open. I shuddered from my shoulders to my hips. It was like thunder. My tits, such as they are, snapped like a couple of wet towels.

“Good ... good girl...” I panted. “Good girl.”

She took her mouth out of my pussy and said, “Happy now?” She had this evil, lop-sided grin.

“Yeah,” I said. “I really am. You still mad I’m not a boy?”

“Not mad.”

“Disappointed.”

“Kinda.”

“Come on!”

“But it’s cool.”

“Oh, thank you.”

But it was cool. When she stopped giggling, and I stopped panting, I said, “Swing around here, you.”

She stuck her pussy in my face, and her head between my legs, and we started all over again.

 

The End

© 2012 by Jacqueline Jillinghoff