Note: This story was dynamically reformatted for online reading convenience. Abby's Surprise (c)1999 Arine Buteft Friday was finally here, and it couldn't have come any sooner. It was the end of May, and finals were being given in classrooms all over the country that week. Middletown wasn't any exception, all week long students had grumbled and groaned, cramming, filling out crib sheets, hoping to brave their last run at test-taking for the year. Abby Mitchell was turning 18 years old in a few weeks, and couldn't wait to get the hell out of high school. Finally graduating, finally getting onto college, she was moving forward and she was pleased with how things had turned out. She was cute, but not drop dead gorgeous, had good grades but not great grades, and was a nice kid, but not a perfect one. She did hang out with some of the wilder girls in the school, two of them, Jenny and Angie were cheerleaders, Kelly was a bathroom smoker who also did a little pot on the weekends, and her best friend Mindy always liked to get out and have a few beers at whatever party was happening that weekend. Abby didn't quite feel comfortable with some of their behavior, but they never forced it on her, so it was OK. Of course she'd had a few drinks before (what high school kid hasn't?), and smoked a joint once. She'd even gotten a little frisky with one of the guys on the soccer team, he'd managed to get her bra off and his hand down her panties before she left him with a bad case of blueballs, but even while she was pushing him away, a part of her was enjoying what he was doing. Still, she wasn't quite ready for that, she told herself, and that was that. Mindy and Abby were the closest of friends, they hardly spent a single day without calling each other, talking in classes, or hanging out, going to the mall, stuff like that. Mindy had a boyfriend, a track athlete named Dan, and the two of them usually went out once a week. Mindy always told Abby every single detail about what she and Dan did, and Abby listened, getting an odd tingle in her stomach hearing her stories. Mindy was always trying to set her up with one guy or the other, but Abby just didn't feel any kind of connection with the guys she picked out. They were always a little too dumb, or a little too macho for her tastes. Still, Mindy wasn't quite ready to give up yet. Driving away from school that afternoon in Mindy's car, the two of them hollered and shouted about how cool it was that school was finally over! "You know," Mindy started, "you're going to meet so many cute guys at Northwestern, you won't believe it!" She giggled as Abby blushed, turning away. "You always are so concerned about my love life, don't worry, I'm doing just fine," she said with a smile. She sighed, leaned back, and closed her eyes, thinking about the upcoming graduation, and the summer that lay ahead. When she opened them again, she couldn't figure out where Mindy was taking them. Anticipating Abby's question, Mindy said "I'm going to my sister's apartment, I had her get some stuff for the party tonight. You know, beer, liquor, shit like that." Abby nodded and listened to the radio on the way over. It was a short drive, and Mindy hopped out of the car, promising to return in a minute. When she came back out of the apartment, she was carrying a big garbage bag, hiding a case of beer and a sack with a few bottles in it. "What did you get, "asked Abby? "Bud Light, tequila, and vodka... that should be enough for a little party!" Mindy smiled broadly. "And just where is this party, you know your parents would freak if you tried to pull that at home!" Mindy just smiled, and said, "don't worry." A few minutes later Abby recognized Dan's neighborhood and realized where the party was going to be. They got there, and Mindy hopped out first, excited at the thought of the fun in store for the evening. Dan came out, just having gotten home a few minutes earlier, and helped Mindy carry the stuff in. He also gave her a deep kiss and squeezed Mindy's ass as Abby looked away, a little embarrassed at their antics. There were still a few hours to kill before things were going to get started, so the three of them went out for pizza, and Mindy needed to run to the mall and look at a cool new top she'd seen at one of the trendy little stores. Abby helped her pick things out while Dan fidgeted behind them, uncomfortable in a clothing store. The girls noticed his behavior and giggled at his unease, and Dan shot them a dirty look. It was about 7:00pm now, and the three of them were back at Dan's place setting things up. Well there wasn't too much to set up, the case of beer that Mindy brought plus another two that Dan had arranged to get, some glasses and ice, orange juice, margarita mix, and the usual chips and snack foods. By 7:30, the first guys started showing up. Abby was a bit uncomfortable, all of the people who were arriving were friend's of Dan, and she felt a little alone with Mindy and Dan sitting close on the couch, leaving her alone on the other couch. Mike and Dave were the first two, then Kevin and his girlfriend Laura came a few minutes later. Abby couldn't stand Laura, she was such a bitch to her, always so stuck up and snobbish. Finally at about 8:00 Abby's three other friends showed up, already a little drunk. Giddy and giggling, they plopped down next to Abby on the couch. "Hiya Abi, hey, isn't it cool that we're done with high school? Woo hoo!" Kelly shouted, bouncing on the couch. Abby giggled at her display and agreed, and sincerely meant it. Kelly leaned over and whispered into Abby's ear. "Hey Abby, you wanna get stoned tonight?" She asked. Abby was about ready to blow her off, when something stopped her. She wasn't sure what, but a little voice said 'come on, live a little!', and so Abby nodded. A little surprised, Kelly paused for a second, then jumped off the couch and took Abby the hand, leading her back out into Dan's backyard. "I can't believe you're getting stoned tonight, you've never even had any before!" "Yes I have you moron, remember last summer when you gave me a few hits on your joint?" Abby said back, laughing. "Ooohhh yeah, well hey I was stoned that night too, can you blame me for forgetting?" They both burst out laughing, and Kelly lit the roll. She took a few puffs, then one deep drag and passed to Abby while she held it in. Abby did the same, and the two traded off for a few minutes like that, not saying anything. Abby was feeling herself getting really lightheaded, the only other time she'd had pot, she just took two or three puffs, and hardly felt anything. This was very different, she felt very calm, and it seemed like the whole world consisted of Kelly, herself, and the joint. She sat down on a lawn chair on the patio and leaned back, eyes closed. "Feels pretty fucking cool, doesn't it," Kelly asked her. Abby just smiled and nodded, making a 'mmmm' sound. She didn't even notice as Mike came out, beers in his hands. "Hey Abby, you want one of these?" he asked, holding the can out to her. She opened her eyes a bit, took the can, and mumbled "thanks" as she popped the lid open. Mike came over to Kelly and asked to make sure that Abby was really stoned, he couldn't believe it! Kelly just giggled again, grabbed the beer and shooed him off. It was OK, Mike didn't want to smoke anyway, he was just trying to play bartender, he loved doing that. It was starting to get a little chilly out, and after their third joint, Kelly and Abby wandered inside. They were a little surprised to find the place almost empty, in fact, it was just Dan and Mindy making out on one couch, and Kevin and Laura on the other. Jenny and Angie came out of the kitchen, Angie helping to guide Jenny along. It was pretty obvious she'd had too much to drink, fortunately Angie had stayed sober enough to drive back home. Abby was shocked to look at the clock and see it at 11:00pm, it had been almost three hours since she'd gone outside on the porch! It didn't seem that long... "Kelly, come on, I'm taking Jenny home!" Angie barked, a little impatient. Kelly gave Abby a 'what can I do' look, shrugged, and waved bye to her. "Don't have too much fun while I'm gone Abby!" she said as she walked out the door, careful to use the furniture on the way over to guide herself. Abby stood in the middle of the entryway, looking back in on the scene before her. She sighed, knowing that Mindy was her ride home (she sure as hell wasn't getting in a car with Laura!), and walked over to the makeshift bar. She wasn't sure how many beers she'd had, or how much of her pleasant fuzzy feeling was due to the alcohol and how much was due to the pot, but she was past caring. She opened a beer, sat down on the easy chair, and started flipping channels while the two couples were having their fun on either side of her. She really didn't even notice, becoming fascinated with some dumb movie on TV, you know, the ones about the wild and crazy college kids who are up to no good. She wondered if she'd end up like that next year, and started to giggle at the thought. Dark and fuzzy, she opened her eyes and looked around. Abby had passed out on the couch for about an hour, it was close to midnight now. There wasn't anyone in the living room now, and she was starting to sober up. The pot had worn off too, she didn't really feel sick, just a little off. She walked over to the kitchen, and poured a glass of water from the faucet. Sounds were coming down the stairs now, Dan and Mindy coming into the living room again. "Hey girl, Kelly says you got really stoned!" Mindy said, smiling. "Yeah I can't believe it, you of all people, miss prim and proper!" Dan added. Abby just groaned and told them to fuck off, and wandered back to the living room to lay down on the couch. "So I let loose a little bit, what's wrong with that?" she asked accusingly. Mindy sat down next to her, opening a beer. "Hey I think it's cool that you could have some fun, I'm all for it!" She smiled at Abby and started to drink her beer. Dan came over and sat down on the couch too, this time sitting down between the two of them. Abby wondered what he was doing, there was plenty of room on the other side of Mindy. She looked at Mindy, who was looking back with a strange expression on her face. Dan leaned over and started to kiss Mindy, his hand reaching out to squeeze her breast. Mindy gasped a little and returned his kiss, leaning forward into him. She was now pushing on him, leaning him back against Abby. Abby was frozen, she didn't know what to do as Dan's upper body began to press against hers. Dan turned on the couch to face Abby, looking at her intently as he leaned over. She caught the look in his eyes, and didn't know what to make of it. Her heart was starting to beat harder. Abby didn't move as he pressed his lips to hers, softly at first, then firmer. Instinctively, she melted into his kiss and returned it, feeling his hand running up her thigh. Realizing what was happening, she broke the kiss with a start, backing away from him. "Abby it's OK, I want to share Dan with you tonight, and I think he wants you too, don't you honey?" Abby couldn't believe what Mindy was saying! Her mind was racing at the though, totally unsure of what to do next. Partially scared, and a little curious, she simply sat there on the couch, waiting. Mindy sat up and crawled over to Dan, wrapping her arms around his chest and rubbing it as she stared into Abby's eyes. Abby was confused, but at the same time, those odd feelings in her stomach were returning, thinking about the stories she'd heard about Dan and Mindy together. "Just relax, Abby," he said, leaning back down to kiss her. Abby amazed herself, she was kissing him back while at the same time her mind was fighting to push him away. Seconds passed, and gradually, that voice in her mind grew quieter and quieter, as Dan's deep kiss melted her. He broke away, kissed Mindy again, and then returned to Abby's mouth. Abby had no problem returning this time, she was kissing passionately, tongue darting into his mouth, breathing harder. She reached out with her arms to take his shoulders, and he leaned over her, pushing her back onto the couch. The two of them continued to french as Mindy got off of the couch and crawled on the floor to sit directly in front of the action, watching intently. Dan now had his hands up Abby's shirt, roaming freely over her breasts, squeezing and fondling them through her bra. She gasped a little when he pinched one of her nipples, but continued to kiss him back. She arched her back a little, tits sticking out prominently. Abby had smallish ones, only a B cup, but Dan didn't seem to mind one bit. Her shirt came off next, and they broke the kiss, both panting as she held her arms up for him to remove it. Abby lay back on the pillows, chest heaving, lacy white bra rising and falling. Mindy's eyes were glued to the scene, and she licked her lips. Abby could see Mindy's nipples poking through her shirt, she must have lost her bra earlier tonight with Dan. "Take off her bra, Dan," she told him. Dan didn't even acknowledge the command, but obeyed just the same. He reached behind her back, never losing eye contact, and unhooked it. He pushed it off her shoulders, and tossed it aside. Abby waited, breathing hard, as her nipples stiffened in the open air. She had dark, prominent ones, with little aureoles and stiff points. She'd never been this naked before another person in her life, let alone her best friend and boyfriend. The whole idea of what they were doing seemed so strange and exciting at the same time, she found herself growing wet. His hands reached out to touch her nipples, playing just a little, rubbing and teasing. She leaned her head back and let out a little whimper as the sensations flowed through her body. Eyes closed, she was unprepared for his next action, feeling his mouth close around the left nipple, she gasped and jerked a little, but did nothing to stop him. He continued to play and stroke her nipples, kissing her breasts all over, squeezing and fondling them. When she opened her eyes again, she was shocked again: Mindy was topless too, playing with her own boobs while she watched. Abby had never seen Mindy naked before, and she felt so strange when a tingle of excitement flooded her brain, spreading through her body. Her heart was racing, and she knew that without a doubt she would be losing her virginity tonight. She was very damp now, she could feel the wetness every time she shifted and moved her hips. "Take her shorts off now." Abby's heart leapt in her chest at Mindy's words, knowing what was to come next. Dan again responded, reaching his hands down to Abby's waistline, unhooking the button on her little denim shorts, and unzipping them. Abby closed her eyes again, waiting for the inevitable contact on her pussy... YES! His fingers brushed her clit as he pulled her shorts and panties off at the same time, and she shifted her hips to make contact with his hand again. Dan lifted her butt off the couch, and finished pulling the jeans shorts off of her. The next thing Abby knew, his strong hands were on her inner thighs, spreading her legs open. She could feel how wet she was, juices lubricating her sex, hidden behind a tuft of dark hair. Abby began to whimper involuntarily, wanting to feel something touching her clitoris again. She was rewarded in a few seconds with a soft kiss on each thigh, trailing in to her pussy. The kisses turned into licks, running up and down her lips, probing her depths. She squeezed her legs a bit, trying to force more contact, when she felt something strange. Realizing that the lack of beard stubble, she opened her eyes to find Mindy's head nestled between her legs, kissing her pussy! Abby jerked back, and Mindy looked up, face wet with her juices, smiling. Abby was frozen, and could do nothing to resist when Mindy lowered her face again. She groaned loudly, as Mindy played her tongue across Abby's clit, applying just the right amount of pressure. Abby had lost all resistance, she knew that she would be powerless to Mindy and Dan's actions. She gasped again, as Mindy kissed her clitoris, and sank down into the couch, giving in fully to her passion. Dan was watching now, standing in front of both of them, stroking his cock. Abby opened her eyes to look at him again, playing with himself. Dan walked around the side of the couch, and stood right next to Abby, his cock just inches from her face. Abby stared at it as he stroked it, and reached out her own hand to touch it. It was hot, and she could feel it throb as she grasped it around the base. Not even sure of what she was doing, she started to jerk his cock, all the while being eaten out by Mindy. Abby was unable to keep quiet now, and began groaning and gasping with each movement of Mindy's mouth on her cunt. She had become so disoriented that she let go of his cock and sunk into the couch even further, legs on Mindy's shoulders. Dan took his cock in his hand again, continuing to stroke it while he watched the scene. Abby had never reached such a peak before, not even the few times she'd played with herself, this was totally different, being eaten out, and by her best friend too! Mindy was an expert at what she was doing, and Abby half wondered if this was the first time Mindy had been with another woman. She didn't really care, she could hardly think about anything with her heart racing, chest heaving, as she grew closer and closer to coming. Dan leaned over now, and began to suck and fondle her breasts like before, and that put her over the edge. With a short yelp, her body exploded, every nerve ending in her pussy coming alive as Mindy attacked her clit with her tongue... Abby stiffened, muscles shaking as her body rode out the intense wave of passion. Finally, after what seemed to be an eternity, she gasped for air again, and felt her clit growing super sensitive. Mindy stopped her direct kissing and sucking on her clit, and instead slipped a finger up inside Abby. Panting as her orgasm faded, still feeling its effects, Abby opened her eyes and looked down at Mindy, smiling up at her. Mindy climbed up her body, running her hands over Abby's sensitive breasts, coming up to kiss her deeply. Abby returned the kiss, tasting her own cum on Mindy's lips. The salty, tangy taste excited Abby, and for a moment she wondered if Mindy tasted the same. Mindy sat over on the couch now, next to Abby, and motioned for Dan to come over. "Abby, aren't you going to thank Dan for what he did to you?" Mindy asked, eyeing Abby mischievously. Abby didn't understand for a second, then seeing Dan's cock pointing at her, she got it. Awkwardly, she got on the floor in front of the couch, on her knees. Dan's cock swayed in front of her, and he reached out to take Abby's hand and guide it to his cock. "Good, start stroking it first, get him worked up, " Mindy said, her hands trailing over her own breasts, pinching her nipples and sliding a hand down to her pussy. She watched as Abby's hand circled Dan's cock, barely able to get her fingers around it. She started pulling on it slowly, then speeded up a bit. Dan let out a groan, and his breathing picked up. "Now start licking his cock," Mindy commanded, her hands playing with her cunt as she watched Abby. Abby hesitated at first, then brought her mouth close to his cock. Almost shyly, she stuck her tongue out and started to lick around his cockhead. Dan groaned a bit louder now, and his hips were beginning to jerk in response. Abby seemed to relax, and closed her lips around his head, swirling her tongue around and sucking a little. "Good girl, you know what he likes. Try and suck a little more, but don't take too much in. Just play with his cock and do what you're doing." Abby didn't even hear Mindy, she was in a world of her own. She had one hand wrapped around the base of his cock, squeezing and pumping, while the other one came up to play with his balls. She started sucking a little more of his shaft, not too much, but enough to get Dan really worked up. He was apparently plenty horny, no doubt from Mindy teasing him all night. Abby could tell she was doing things right, Dan was groaning and gasping with every swirl of her tongue. All of these new feelings and sensations were wonderful, she was going beyond any limits she'd ever imagined herself reaching, and she liked what she was doing. Her tongue was circling, licking, lips smacking loudly. She experimented with squeezing his shaft tight, until he thought his cock was going to burst, then letting it go, taking more of him in her mouth. The third time she did that, he had had enough. "Oh shit!" he yelled, hips jerking erratically as his cock surged. Abby was unprepared for his cum, it flooded her mouth and ran out. She took her mouth away, keeping her hand tight around his shaft as he continued to jerk. She was fascinated at the sight of cum shooting out of his dick, landing on her face and tits. He gave a few more jerks with his hips, and then finally stopped moving. Abby tasted the cum in her mouth, and found it to be OK, not wonderful, but definitely something she could get used to, if it meant getting the same in return! Exhausted, he flopped on the couch, laying spread out, gasping. Abby stayed on her hands and knees, playing with the cum all over her body. She rubbing it around, feeling how slippery and sticky it was, still warm from being inside him. Mindy got back on the floor, on her knees just like Abby, and started to kiss her. Licking the cum, sharing it in their kiss, rubbing it into Abby's breasts. Abby was so turned on by this, she almost came again just from the kissing. Her heart was racing again, and she felt the wetness growing again between her legs. The two of them kissed for another minute, before Mindy broke the embrace. She lay down on the floor now, parallel to the couch. She opened her legs, and ran a hand down to play with herself again.. Her lips were thick and reddish, engorged with blood and slick with her wetness. Pulling a pillow off the couch to place under her head, she rested back, and waited. Abby watched, knowing what she was to ask next. "Abby, come over here and kiss my pussy." Abby was there in seconds, lying down on the ground in front of Mindy. She started to lick right away, tasting her wetness. Mindy had the same tart, salty taste that Abby's own pussy had, and the smell of it was enough to get her juices flowing out again, she could feel them running over her cunt, sticky from Mindy's saliva. "Abby, get up on your hands and knees. I want Dan to eat you out while you do it to me," Mindy told her. Abby let out a pleased sound, and responded immediately, rising up so that Dan could lie on his back and scoot his head under to her pussy. Abby groaned again as she felt a pair of lips make contact with her sex. "Ooohhh...mmm..." was all she said before Mindy forced her face back into her pussy. Abby continued to groan into Mindy's cunt as she felt Dan's mouth on her. Dan had a totally different style than Mindy. He started by licking deep strokes up and down her lips, and then inserted a finger, beginning to slip it in and out. Abby felt her hips begin to move in response to his finger fucking, while at the same time grinding her pussy into his face on each downstroke. Abby was getting lost in her passion again, and Mindy had to assist by using her own fingers to stimulate herself. Abby licked and kissed Mindy's pussy between groans and moans, trying to taste every inch of her. Abby watched as she licked, as Mindy's fingers rubbed slow circles around her clit, then fast up and down over it, alternating between light and deep pressure. Groaning and gasping, Abby gave up on her efforts, and just mashed her face into Mindy's pussy, letting Mindy do the work of grinding her hips into Abby's face. Abby was almost screaming now, Dan was doing a great job of teasing her clit, and she was anxious for more. "Lick me Dan, ooohh yes, mmmm... that's so good..." she was saying over and over, hearing herself talking like that was turning her on even more. Abby couldn't last much longer, and Mindy knew it, so Mindy speeded up her own orgasm, bringing herself to a quick but intense climax as Abby groaned into her pussy. Abby did best to lick up the flowing juices as she came closer and closer to her peak. When Dan took her clit into his mouth and sucked deeply on it, drawing it in and tonguing it. That was too much for Abby, and she came again, letting out a scream as her body exploded for the second time that night. It was too intense for her, and she collapsed on the floor, trying to catch her breath. Mindy and Dan crawled over to each other and kissed deeply, Mindy still in the afterglow of her orgasm. Abby recovered her strength and rolled over to look at Dan and Mindy kissing, and Dan's cock stiff again. Mindy started tugging on it, much the same as Abby had earlier. "Dan, I think it's time you made Abby a woman, I think she's been waiting long enough." Mindy caught Abby's gaze, staring at Dan's now erect shaft. "On the couch Abby." Abby crawled up on the couch and propped her head up on a pillow. She waited, staring at his cock, knowing where it would be in just a matter of seconds. "Good, now spread your legs, wide. Let Dan see that cute pussy of yours." Abby felt a surge in her cunt hearing Mindy talk that way. "Play with yourself. Good. Rub your clit. Faster." Mindy was clearly getting off on directing the show. She was playing with her own pussy as she told Abby what to do. "Dan, I think she's ready." Smiling, Dan climbed on the couch, bringing himself up Abby's body. She was breathing hard, anticipating what was coming. She felt Dan's cock poking her inner thigh as he slid up her body. His weight over her felt good, she felt meek and submissive. She stared down the length of his body, still looking at his cock. "I think she likes what she sees," Dan noted. Mindy moved over to the side of the couch, and took Dan's cock in her hand. Guiding it, she first rubbed it over Abby's throbbing pussy. Precum had started to leak from his cock, and Mindy mixed their juices around, as she moved his cock. Abby was whimpering as she felt his cockhead nestle between her lips. Mindy felt Dan's cock catch in her opening, and paused, driving them both crazy with anticipation. Dan and Abby were both slaves to Mindy's control, she was in charge. She held Dan's cock tight, as he began to enter her. Abby let out a deep sigh as she felt herself being filled up with her first cock. Mindy held on, only allowing two inches inside, before she tugged him out. She was tight, and very wet, as slippery as any woman Dan had been with. Dan started to surge forward, but Mindy stopped him. She was going to make this last for herself. They both groaned as Mindy withdrew him, then groaned louder when she directed him in again. She pulled him back out one last time, then simply gave one last command. "Fuck her," she whispered, and Dan was deep inside of her the next instant. Abby cried out at first, then relaxed as she grew accustomed to feeling Dan inside of her. Mindy's relentless teasing had driven them both to the edge, and she knew that Dan would not last long. He started out with deep, slow thrusts, but after only a minute he had increased his pace. He began pounding her pussy, their sweating bodies slapping obscenely as they rocked together. His groaning picked up in intensity as he drove into Abby, and she took every inch of him, grinding back with each of his thrusts. They kissed for a moment, but couldn't maintain it, they were gasping too hard. Abby closed her eyes, taking in only the sounds and sensations of their sex, his moaning, the sounds of their bodies slapping, his sweaty skin on hers, rock hard cock probing her pussy. She felt his cock jerk again, and he yelled out as he came inside of her. His butt tightened, pressing his whole cock inside of her, completely filling her up. She groaned with him, her hands pulling him in, feeling his cock spasming inside of her. Gasping for air, he finally stopped grinding on top of Abby, pulling out his softening cock. Abby looked down at the sight, his cock withdrawing from inside of her, a sticky trail of white clinging to him as he pulled away. She moved her hand down to her pussy, and she could feel the cum he had left inside of her beginning to run out. Mindy knelt down at her pussy once again, and began licking the cum off of her. That was all Abby could take, and she came for the third time, a quick, intense orgasm that left her dizzy. When she regained her senses, Mindy was finishing cleaning up her pussy with quick, catlike licks. They kissed again, and Abby could taste the combination of Dan's cum and her own wetness in Mindy's mouth. Abby felt Dan sliding his arms under her, lifting her off the couch. Abby felt totally content, relaxed, and very, very tired. Together, they walked up to Dan's bedroom, where they all fell asleep laying on each other. The next thing any of them knew, it was morning. The three of them laid in Dan's bed, covers strewn about. Dan was absent-mindedly stroking Abby's breasts while Mindy watched intently. They all spent the next half hour just playing around, thinking about what just happened that night. Abby was the first to speak. "You know, we've still got a whole summer together before college..." The End