The Little Thief pt2 Payton woke feeling groggy and sore all over, mainly his ass. His mind slowly came around to semi full consciousness and began to register the aches and pains of his body, also that he was naked. His arms felt numb like he had been sleeping on them and when he tried to move them they felt stuck. His feet and ankles tingled with pins and needles also, when he tried to move them they felt stuck together. He slowly began to remember the events that happened before he fell asleep, realizing his arms were bound as were his legs. A rush of panic began to well up in him as he struggled to free his hands, finding his bindings not giving an inch. Small grunts and whines of fear emitted from him with his struggles, soon evolving into sobs. He raised his head to look around his room, the sun was setting and darkness was filling his room, he rolled to his side to look at his door and was surprised to see Sandy standing there watching him with a smile fit for a sadist. He started to say something to her about letting him go but his mouth was so dry his tongue stuck to the roof of his mouth, a dry cracked noise came from his throat instead. "What's wrong? You want let loose?" His sister taunted enjoying her brother's predicament. He vigorously nodded his head pleading with his eye, he tried to work some saliva up to wet his mouth so he could speak. Sandy gave an evil giggle and approached her brother laying bound on his bed. Payton noticed her shirt was stained down the front of it with white spots like she had dribbled something down herself, her hair was all messed up like she had just gotten out of bed. Then he noticed her skirt was missing because he saw her plump but tiny pussy peeking out from under the hem of her shirt, he felt his dick begin to firm even with his sore bound body parts. "Did you have fun with Dave?" Sandy asked him as she sat on the edge of the bed, her light weight sinking it down slightly. Payton's eyes bulged when he heard her say Dave's name, a flood of memories rushed back into his mind. He remembered the feeling of fear when Dave had grabbed him from rutting in Sandy, binding his hands and feet. The feeling of Dave's large cock piercing his ass for the first time as his mother watched from the doorway. He also remembered with some shame and humiliation at Dave's cock starting to feel good and how he had begged Dave to do it more. Payton looked over at his little sister with embarrassment as he remembered her watching him get sodomized, his cheeks glowing red as he saw the knowing look in Sandy's eye's. "Let me go" he managed to squeak out from his parched mouth, trying to sound in command of his emotions. Sandy just giggled and shook her head no, sending Payton into a fit of rage. He bounced and twisted his body trying to get loose, his legs and arms straining against the leather belts. Sandy watched his tantrum with glee, she was enjoying her brother's discomfort, she figured it was good payback for all the times he was mean to her. Payton soon gave up his struggles in frustration, tears began to form in his eyes as he realized he couldn't get free. He turned his face to Sandy so he could plead to be freed again but when he saw what she was holding he froze in fear. "Where did you get that?" His voice croaked as he eyed the pink vibrator in her hand. A devious smile appeared on her face as she held it up for him to see. "It's mine... Mom gave it to me a few months back." She wiggled it in front of his face. Payton had a vague recollection of that pink vibrator sticking out of her ass while he was being fucked by Dave, but didn't know it was her vibrator. "When you first started to try and fuck me, Mom gave it to me to help open me up so it would be easier to let you in. She said it wouldn't hurt as much and she was right." Sandy pulled it back to her chest ad gave it a hug, twisting back and forth. "I just love this thing." Then she stopped moving at gave her brother a serious look, her happy face melting into a somber stare. "Speaking of the first time you fucked me..." She crawled closer to her brother, approaching his waist, " I still owe you for that. It hurt and you didn't do anything to stop or make me feel better." Her tiny hand came down hard on one of his bare asscheeks making a loud smack and leaving a light red mark in the shape of her hand. Payton jerked and yelped at the stinging blow to his soft ass meat, fear and panic returned as he listened to her soft ominous voice. He started to say something when he felt her hand hit him again hard in the same spot, making him flex his ass and suck in air from the pain. "Owwwie... Stop it Sis!!" He exclaimed as she hauled off and wacked him a third time, shaking her stinging hand afterwards. Sandy stopped but not because he had told her to, her hand was sore from hitting his soft but tight bottom. She crawled over his thighs sitting with her knees on either side of him, her tiny butt resting on his lower thighs just above his knees. Since he was face down he couldn't do anything to dislodge his sister's sitting position and he knew she was in the perfect spot to do anything she wanted to him. Payton lay there waiting nervously for something to happen, feeling her move and shift on top of him. He desperately tried to think of something to do, he tried to roll over but she leaned her weight onto his hips pinning him to the bed, an evil laugh came from the girl as she dominated him. He had always had his way with her, making her do the things he wanted, now it was her turn. Sandy leaned back a little giving herself access to her brother's ass, reaching down she spread one of his cheeks to look at his bud. Payton tried to clench his cheeks together to deny her access but a sharp strike from Sandy made him relax. Sandy pulled the meaty flesh apart and peered at the reddish sore looking asshole of her big brother. A small whine came from Payton as his asshole stung from being stretched by buttcheek, his hands clenched as he tries to ignore the pain. Sandy not caring about her brother's discomfort pointed her finger down to touch his twitching asshole, her finger pushed and prodded around the squishy softness of his delicate flesh. Payton jumped and said ouch every time she made contact with his abused asshole. Sandy looked like a junior scientist studying an experiment, a solid look of fascination and discovery on her face as she examined him. Satisfied with her finger exploration she grabbed the pink vibrator laying next to her, giving a twist of the end to turn it on she lowered it towards her brother's butt. Payton froze and felt a tingling running down his back from the sound of the vibrator, he began to buck and protest knowing where it was heading. Sandy had to hold on as her brother fought under her in a frantic attempt to get away, all for naught though it just managed to ware him out more. He lay there panting and pleading with his sister to not do it. His voice had come back to him and was beginning to get quite loud, Sandy was worried her mom or Dave might come in and stop her, or worse take over. She spotted her panties from earlier, the ones used to shut him up. She knew she had to be quick or Payton would use the chance to roll over or ball up, so she waited until she thought the time was right and leap forward to grab the panties before crawling backwards quickly back in place. Payton felt her move suddenly but was too surprised by the move to do anything about it, he had no idea what she was doing until he saw her grab the soiled panties. He tried to move but Sandy was back on top of him before he could do anything, a frustrated grunt escaped him as her weight landed back on his legs. The he felt her grab his forehead pulling his head back, her hand pulled painfully on his skin making him say 'Aaah'. She reached around his head and stuffed the dirty panties into his face, his throat and tongue reacting to the horrible taste. He felt crusty bits in the cloth that scrapped the inside of his mouth, his saliva immediately dried up as the panties absorbed the slimy liquid. Payton gave a hard retch as the odor of stale girl musk, Dave's dried jizz and his own old saliva filled his head rehydrated from his mouth moisture. Sandy was quite pleased with the retching sounds coming from her brother, her pussy tingled from the excitement of dominating him. She kind of understood now why her brother liked doing nasty things to her. She felt a rush of power knowing he was completely helpless and she could do anything she wanted to him. She didn't want to hurt him though, well not to badly, she just wanted to rough him up like he did her. She eyed his butt again, grabbing the still vibrating toy, she lowered the pink device to his asshole touching the tip of it to his quivering sphincter. Payton gave a shocked guttural sound followed by a hard retch into the panties, the feeling of the vibrations on his tender asshole were not what he was expecting. He had been expecting something horrible like when Dave first entered him, piercing hot pain. Instead he felt a fluttery feeling deep inside his guts even though the vibrator hadn't penetrated him yet. It felt like something was buzzing inside of his stomach or just below it, it felt strange and good at the same time. He remembered that Dave's cock had felt similar at one point but the feeling of being filled fully up on the insides had overpowered the gut feeling. This was an intense gut feeling with a surprising amount of pleasure growing inside him, his little dick was swelling to a modest cock user him. The sheets felt good on his harding cock and he couldn't help but move his hips some. Sandy misinterpreting his hip movements as an attempt to get away from her pink friend pushed against his puckering hole. She felt solid resistance against her efforts as Payton flexed and squeezed his ass as hard as he could. The pressure from her prod had rudely interrupted his new enjoyment of anal stimulation, causing that sharp pain he had been dreading to burst through his ass. He desperately wanted her to stop and didn't know his efforts to stop her was making the process even more painful. That and the fact that Sandy hadn't bothered to use any lube, it was payback after all. Payton began to realize that maybe he did deserve some of this, if this hurt his butt this much it must have really hurt Sandy when he first did it with her. She had been crying and pleading for him to stop and he hadn't really gotten his dick into her, only ruptured her hymen. Then the first time he really got it in her she didn't seem to enjoy it as much as he did, but he never cared before. She was just his stupid little sister and when mom wasn't willing or able to please him Sandy would do. Now he realized how much of an asshole he had been, that this was because he had done so many bad things to people. Even Dave who had taken his anal virginity, Payton had stolen a bunch of stuff from him and Dave had come over for revenge. Payton began to see how his actions led to his current situation and he gave up, deciding he deserved this punishment. Maybe if he treated people better they would treat him better, maybe even make him feel good. So he relaxed and completely quit moving, a long exhale from his nose signaling his resignation. Sandy felt her brother go limp under, her face screwed up in confusion at his sudden demeanor. She leaned to the side to look at his face and saw a look of total defeat on his face, suddenly it didn't feel so good to her. "Eh what you giving up?" She asked indignantly, lifting the vibrator from his ass. Her brothers head nodded slightly and she felt kinda sorry for him. Her pity didn't last for long though she still owed him and she pointed the vibrator towards his ass again but still had problems getting the device to enter her brother. Then she remembered the petroleum jelly her mom had asked for. Looking around she remembered it wasn't in the room and jumped off Payton to retrieve it. She ran as fast as she could hoping to get the jar before Payton could get in a position difficult for her to have her way with. Payton lay there for a second waiting to see if his sister was tricking him in some way but when he heard her footsteps run down the hall he began to flop and try to roll around. His arms behind his back made it difficult for him to roll over on his back and his legs being tied made sure he didn't move very far. Add to that his breathing was restricted from the panties in his mouth making him short of breath faster then he normally would have been. He was almost off the bed when Sandy ran back into the room giving him a dirty scowl. "Na uh Big Brother..." She chortled as she pushed him back over onto his stomach giving a girlish grunt as she pushed his weight around. Payton didn't fight her, just looked at her with the same puppy dog eyes hoping for release. Sandy popped the top off the jar and stuck the tip of the still vibrating dildo into the jelly, laughing a little as it jiggled the substance in the jar. She pulled it out and dabbed a little glob of the jelly into Payton's ass. Then with slow deliberate pressure she reapplied the vibrator to his anus, surprised at how easier the thing moved past his anal ring. Payton gave a sharp gasp when he felt the humming prob enter his ass, his guts quivering from shock and new stimulation. Sandy giggled at his muffled gasp and pushed a little more into him amazed to find little resistance. Payton bit down on the panties in his mouth as he felt his anus begin to fill with buzzing plastic, his guts felt like something filling him up from the bottom up as vibrations traveled up his body. The pressure from the invader made him feel uncomfortable but at the same time it felt oddly good, just as Dave's cock had felt earlier. His cock stiffened to full hardness as sandy began to twist the vibrator around a little in her brother butt. His ass moved around in different directions, sometimes towards her movements and sometimes away, she was having a difficult time of keeping control over the vibrator. One point it slipped from her greasy grip and popped loose from his ass flipping onto the bed and rolling around humming. Payton's ass movement stopped once the vibrator left his ass, he panted deeply through his nose trying not to gag on the fabric in his mouth. Sandy picked up the vibrator and unceremoniously shoved it back in where it came from, probably a little harder than she needed to since it slipped half way into the boy making him kick the bed with both feet while trying to arch his back away from the quick jab of pain. His muffled and garbled scream could barely be heard outside the room thanks to those panties. The fabric of the panties inched their way into his throat making him gag hard mid scream his body tensed at the hard retch, Sandy watched with fascination as his ass clenched and the kind vibrator began to slide back out of him. She put her hand down to stop it's retreat, feeling it try to push it's way out from the force of Payton's squeezing ass muscles. She suddenly got an idea and leaned forward some positioning the vibrator so it was held in place in his ass by the skin above her pussy. She tried to push her hips but felt the vibrator slip between them and almost out of Payton, so she tried again this time placing the humming toy just below her waist at the very top of her crotch. This time when she pushed she felt resistance against her hips and with some more force she felt her hips move towards him, the vibrator sliding back into him. Payton gave another grunt as he felt her push with her hips and felt confused when he felt her body next to his, it felt kinda like when Dave had been fucking him. Sandy relaxed her hips away from him and felt the vibrator slide back out with her hips, pressure from his ass keeping it firmly against her skin. The hum of the vibrator shook her skin and her tiny clit giving her tremendous feelings of pleasure from it and the rush of faux fucking her brother. The feelings of role reversal was new to her and she was enjoying it very much. Her hips began a rhythmic push pull mimicking what she had seen and felt. Her gaze never left the pink shaft slipping into and out of her brother. She realized his hips weren't thrashing about as much and they were beginning to match her movements. Payton wasn't sure when it started to feel good exactly, just that he knew the pain had faded and now his cock thrummed from the vibrations sliding in and out of him. He felt a strange tingling deep in his balls that radiated up through his guts, making him light headed and lightly giddy. His sister's warm body felt wonderful on him as he didn't realize how cold he was till now, her hip motions had become less harsh and more tender as time went on. He heard her moan softly into his ear, an erotic sound of sexual enjoyment, he tried to return the noise but only gagged in the wet cloth. He felt a tiny hand reaching around his face and fingers digging into his mouth, then she pulled the wet nasty panties from his mouth with a slight thawck of wet cloth before tossing them off to the side of the room. Payton adjusted his jaw as he greedily sucked I fresh air through his mouth, an 'ohhh' of pleasure escaping him as Sandy continued her pressing and releasing of the vibrator from his ass. "Thank you Sis." Payton gasped when his voice caught back up to him. He felt her nuzzle the back of his head with the side if her head, a light kiss to his ear surprised him as she leaned back up from him. He felt her stop for a moment and was disappointed when he felt the vibrator working it way out, he was really starting to feel good, when he felt her hands on his wrists. He almost sobbed with joy when he felt her begin to undo the buckle in the belt, wincing a little as she tightened it slightly to release the pin. Then he felt slack give in the belt and his arms flopped to his side's like limp noodles, they were completely numb and he couldn't move them as much he tried. He saw his finger twitch when he tried to move his hand so he knew they still worked, just that it was going to be a wicked painful time in a little bit when the feeling came back. He felt her turn to do his legs and the dildo slipped from his ass, his legs didn't feel any better than his arms did. From the calves down they felt like dead stumps, he lay there puffing and moaning from being able to move finally. His shoulders ached from being wrenched back and he rested them on the bed marveling at how soft it felt. He felt Sandy move again, off of him this time and heard the vibrator switch off. Then he felt her weight shift around the bed as she crawled in front of him. He looked up to see her go from a crawling position to a sitting one, swinging a leg over his head just missing it. She sat there in front of him spread out and sitting up and began to inch herself closer to him. He realized she was moving her crotch towards his face and tried to move but his arms refused to obey. She scooted closer, inching her way next to his face, he turned his face downward and away from her shirt covered crotch. He felt her fingers in his hair pulling his head up and as much as he fought he wasn't able to resist her grip. She lifted her shirt under her chin trapping it and grabbed his hair with the other hand, using both to pull his face and her crotch together. Payton let out a horrified noise as he was smothered into her soft silky quim. He never like to eat pussy, least of his sister's hers always tasted like piss to him. His nose pushed her outer lips apart and he felt a slickness wet the tip of it, making him scrunch up his face. But Sandy was determined to make her brother eat her pussy and began to guide his face around saying "Come on big brother..." She gasped in exertion trying to force him to do what she wanted, "You owe me for letting you go. I could have left you here till Mom decided to let you go." Her logic didn't matter to Payton, he didn't want to do that and finally did the only thing be could think of. He bit lightly into her skin with his teeth expecting her to push him away in pain. Instead she crushed his face with her pelvis while while squealing " ouww'. Her hard pubic bone pressed painfully into his face. Sandy was so worked up from the feelings of power and control she didn't realize how close she was to cumming, Payton's bite had pushed her over the edge hard. Her body convulsed and shook while a ripple of pleasure washed through her. Her hands released Payton's face allowing him to roll away, he was aware for sharp pins and needles beginning in his hands and feet. As Sandy came down from her orgasm Payton lay there in slight agony as the pins and needles sensation spread throughout his afflicted limbs, life slowly returning to them. He was soon able to move his arms, they were really shaky and hurt something fierce. His legs soon joined in on the chorus of pain. He lay there groaning as the blood returned life to his limbs. Sandy didn't say a word as she watched her brother recover, her little hand went down to rub the sore skin where he bit her. Sandy watched her brother regain the use of his limbs and wondered if he was going to get her back somehow. But to her relief he got to his feet slowly, his legs shaking under him. "Where you going?" Sandy asked curiously. Payton didn't look at her but responded as he left the room. "To find Mom!" His footsteps thumping away from his room.